EverBank: A Legacy of Innovation in American Banking

In an era where most people associate banks with massive skyscrapers and impersonal service, EverBank has always been something of an outlier.

Born in Jacksonville, Florida, in the late 1990s, EverBank started out with a clear idea: make banking smarter, more flexible, and more accessible to customers who didn’t necessarily fit into the typical mold.

While most banks in the late 90s were sticking to traditional branches and services, EverBank leaned heavily into online banking at a time when the internet was still considered a risky place to store money.

But that risk paid off.

They offered some of the best interest rates on the market and began to attract customers all over the country—not just in Florida.

People who were tired of their brick-and-mortar banks started to take notice.

From Small Player to National Challenger

One of the things that set EverBank apart early on was its unique approach to banking products.

They introduced high-yield savings accounts, competitive CDs, and even foreign currency accounts—an unusual offering for a relatively small U.S. bank.

These products attracted a wide range of customers, including frequent travelers, expats, and investors who wanted more than just the basics.

Their mortgage lending division also grew quickly, focusing on offering flexible loan options at competitive rates.

It wasn’t long before EverBank was showing up in national rankings, not as the biggest bank—but often as one of the best.

As the bank’s footprint grew, so did its ambitions. It began acquiring other financial institutions, expanding into commercial lending, and positioning itself as more than just an internet bank.

But what really put EverBank on the national map was its 2012 IPO.

By going public, it made a strong statement: this was no longer a regional bank.

It was now playing in the big leagues.

Becoming Part of TIAA

In 2017, EverBank took another major step by agreeing to be acquired by TIAA (Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America), a financial services giant known primarily for its retirement and investment products. The deal made a lot of sense on paper.

TIAA wanted to offer banking products to complement its existing financial services, and EverBank had the infrastructure and customer base to make that possible.

For a few years, EverBank as a brand disappeared.

It became TIAA Bank, and while many of the same services were still available, the identity of the original EverBank faded a bit.

Some longtime customers missed the quirkiness and innovation that had defined EverBank in its early days.

The Comeback Nobody Expected

Then, in 2023, something surprising happened: EverBank was back.

TIAA announced it was spinning off its banking division, selling it to a group of private equity investors. The deal allowed the bank to regain its independence—and with that, its original name.

EverBank was reborn.

But this wasn’t just a branding change.

The new leadership team made it clear that they wanted to return to the roots that had made EverBank successful in the first place: innovation, customer-focused products, and a national reach without the overhead of a traditional bank.

The timing couldn’t have been better. With many large banks focusing on high-net-worth individuals and businesses, a gap had opened up in the market for a bank that served everyday Americans with competitive rates and personalized service.

New Divisions, New Focus

Since regaining its independence, EverBank has launched several new initiatives to expand its offerings.

In late 2024, the bank announced the creation of its Corporate Asset Finance division, designed to help large and mid-sized companies get financing for equipment and other capital needs.

This move signals a deeper push into commercial banking—an area with huge potential for growth.

Not long after, EverBank introduced a Public Finance division aimed at helping local governments and municipalities, especially in underserved areas, get the funding they need for essential services like infrastructure, schools, and emergency services.

And for clients in more specialized fields, EverBank rolled out a Specialty Deposit division focused on tailored solutions for fiduciary clients—think title companies, escrow services, and 1031 exchange firms.

It’s a niche area, but one with steady demand and complex needs that big banks often overlook.

\